| |
Three
Cues is a free electronic newsletter focusing on just three items each
edition taken from GDA Integrated Services' College & University
Environmental Scanning (CUES) and our research. Unlike most higher
education newsletters, Three CUES often looks beyond news about colleges
and universities to review greater social and marketing trends. Three
CUES not only provides information, but also offers observations and
recommendations concerning each topic.
If you would like to receive 3 Cues via e-mail,
please e-mail us and we'll be glad
to add you to our distribution list.
Inside This Edition:
The
Gallup Youth Survey asked 13- to 17-year-olds what are the very strong
needs in their lives. Teens went straight to the emotional requirements.
The "need to be trusted" topped the list, followed closely by the "need
to be understood and loved" and the "need to feel safe and secure where
I live and go to school." In all cases, girls were more likely to give
the strongest rating (a 5 on a scale of 1 to 5), than were boys. (Gallup
Briefing, July 23, 2002)
Observations and Recommendations
While
colleges and universities cannot fulfill students' need for love, they
all can demonstrate trust and trusting behavior as well as safety and
security.
A
common cry among current college students is "the administration treats
us like children." Although there is reason to be skeptical of the
judgment of 18-year-olds, colleges also need to demonstrate trust in
them until proven otherwise. For example, all male Wabash College in
Indiana has the shortest student handbook we have seen. The centerpiece
is a single line pledge that all students take that roughly says:
"On-campus or off-campus, I will always behave as a gentleman." It seems
to work for them. Too often colleges assume there is a need for rules
for all students to control the behavior of a few.
Demonstrating and deserving "trust" is also the key to successfully
positioning or, as some prefer, branding your institution. We suggest
examining your admissions materials to ensure they reflect the
institution accurately. In our surveys of current students, we find
those most likely to withdraw strongly agree with the statement "the
admissions materials I received did not accurately reflect the academic,
social or residential environment." These students trusted the
institution, only to be disappointed.
Also, we suggest gathering groups of first-year students prior to the
Thanksgiving break and ask them what has pleased them most, disappointed
them most or surprised them most about their experience thus far. You
will quickly learn if your materials and presentation of the college are
trustworthy.
Contrary to what we expected, since 9/11 our research does not show an
increased interest among prospective students in a college's safety and
security, so it clearly means safety and security are a "given" in
students' minds. Attention to the details of safety (e.g., panic phones,
lighting) are as important or perhaps more important than a small town
location.
Six Key Consumer Changes
("Understanding the Changing Retail Customer," Karlene Kukovitz,
Circulation Management, May 1, 2002)
1. A composite nation. The
American family is being redefined. For example, there are six million
people living together outside of marriage, including some 600,000
same-sex households. Ethnic diversity is increasing, with minorities now
representing 33% of the population. In addition, there is a growing
emphasis on celebrating ethnic and cultural diversity, rather than on
assimilation, as in the past. Message here: don't assume anything about
a prospective student.
2. "Cueless" customers. Cueless,
that is, from the standpoint of the researcher. Because customers are
more complex than ever, classic demographics have become less useful for
purposes of defining customer groups. For example, teens in over half of
U.S. households are now paying for their own clothes; young people are
increasingly dressing in more sophisticated, mature ways, consuming
costly goods and striving for earlier independence. GDA Integrated
Services has always questioned the benefits to higher education of
geo-demographics because the choice of a college has always been more a
case of attitude and interest than demographics.
3. Increasingly powerful consumers. Consumers'
(read "college-bound students' ") power has been greatly magnified by
the easy availability, through the Internet and other sources, of nearly
limitless information about products and services. Colleges are
increasingly conducting transactions in glass houses. A college-bound
student can easily find a rating of your institution, catch up with
current students who were not pre-selected by the college as
spokespersons, and get third-party endorsements without going to your
institution's Web site or admissions office.
4. The stimulation/sanctuary dichotomy.
College-bound students want more excitement and stimulation from the
college experience. Yet, they are also looking to colleges as a
sanctuary from noise and stress, as places to relax and socialize. This
is the curse of student services administrators: providing both an
exciting and diverse experience without continuing the
"over-programming" many students endured from their parents.
5. Amorphous codes and spaces. The
"rules" are far less predictable than in the past. In addition, young
people are expected to fulfill a growing number of roles -- student,
athlete, musician, friend, etc. As a result of these trends, physical
spaces have also become multi-purpose. Almost any place, including the
home, car or a plane, serves as a working space. Space is no longer what
the college says it is but what the students say it is. In the GDA
Integrated Services' studies, students expect a fully wired residence
hall room with cable, high-speed Internet access and a telephone, but
seven of ten students also expect to study in their rooms. This explains
why so many colleges are moving to the flexibility of wireless Internet
connections.
6. Communities everywhere. People are
constantly looking for opportunities to connect. Eight of ten adults who
use the Web do so to visit sites relating to their hobbies or interests.
Twenty-five million people belong to self-help groups. People are
juggling multiple activities and memberships. They no longer feel the
need to drop one activity before adding another. Because of the
opportunity of "cocooning" in their high-tech residence hall rooms
(described above), students may seek electronic communities outside of
the college or the residence hall. This is a great threat to smaller
institutions that pride themselves on a strong sense of community, and
therefore, is worthy of attention from student services administrators.
Paper
or e-mail? In an effort to be on the cutting edge or to save funds,
don't push your admissions office exclusively to "paperless" materials
quite yet. In GDA Integrated Services' most recent surveys of
college-bound students we asked, "In general, did you prefer getting
your information about colleges in paper format, such as brochures or
personal letters, or electronically, such as e-mails or visits to the
college Web site?" Over six of ten (69%) students said they still
preferred paper followed by about 15% who said electronic materials, 13%
who said both, and 3% who had no preference. Unfortunately, maintaining
both paper materials and electronic materials raises the cost of an
admissions operation, but we see no safe alternative.
Some of the electronic influence in student recruitment is,
unfortunately, out of the hands of the colleges. For example, in GDA
Integrated Services' studies, about half of college-bound students use a
computer search program to find likely colleges. Of those who use such a
search engine, one-third of these students call such programs
"essential" in their choice of a college.
When do college-bound students begin their search for a college? Our
research shows the following:
- 35% before junior year
- 25% first half of junior year
- 30% second half of junior through summer before their senior
year
- 10% beginning of senior year
Interestingly, when the search begins seems to parallel the first time
college-bound students take the PSATs or ACTs. While only 10% of the
students take one of these tests as freshmen in high school, 40% say
they first took the test in their sophomore year. Forty-five percent say
they first took one of the standardized tests in the junior year.
Remember when taking the PSATs was a junior-year activity? It also
explains why the response to direct mail is highest among students who
take the PSATs/ACTs before their junior year. But, if your sophomore
search responses are down from recent years, blame it on your Web site.
Seven of ten college-bound students went to a college's Web site before
they actually inquired about that college. For direct mail this may mean
your mail is catching their attention, but instead of returning the
inquiry form, they jump on your Web site. If they like what they see,
many inquire directly on line. If your institution's Web inquiries have
not gone up, you may wish to re-examine the "interactivity" of the site.
GDA
Integrated Services is a market research, consulting and services firm
that specializes in customized, integrated marketing solutions that help
colleges and universities compete successfully for students, funding,
and visibility in the twenty-first century.
|